Download:
-
Plague is an acute and severe infectious disease that is usually found in rodents but can spread to humans and seriously impact health and socio-economic development (1). By the end of 2021, there were 12 types of natural plague foci in the mainland of China, located in 322 county-level divisions of 19 provincial-level administrative divisions (PLADs), covering a total of 1,587,666.67 square kilometers. In 2021, one non-fatal case of human plague occurred in China.
Primary level prevention measures, including active surveillance and periodic epizootic plague risk assessments, are known effective methods to prevent the spread of plague from animals to humans. Based on the epidemiological situation of plague in the past 20 years in China, we identify high-risk areas in 2022 to provide support for domestic plague prevention and control policy.
We used risk matrix and Borda count methods to conduct a risk assessment of plague foci in China based on the frequency of human plague epidemics and plague epizootics and other relevant factors — plague foci, etiology, transmission characteristics, and hygiene practices (2-3). The data used in our analyses are from the “Information System for Plague Prevention and Control” and annual surveillance reports from PLADs.
Plague epizootics or positive indications were found for 5 types of natural plague foci (Marmota himalayanain Qinghai-Tibet Plateau,Meriones unguiculatusin Inner Mongolia Plateau,Marmota baibacina-Spermophilus undulatusin Tianshan Mountains,Microtus fuscusin Qinghai-Tibet Plateau,Rhombomys opimusin Junggar Basin), located in 33 county-level divisions of 7 PLADs and 1 regiment farm of Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps. Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region had 9 country-level foci: Xizang (Tibet) Autonomous Region had 8; Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region had 7; Gansu Province had 5; Sichuan Province had 2; and Qinghai Province and Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region each had 1.
From 2002 to 2021, plague epizootics or positive indications were found for 12 types of natural plague foci in 196 county-level divisions of 16 PLADs. In terms of plague foci, there were 458 occurrences ofMarmota himalayanaplague in 85 counties, 60 occurrences ofRattus flavipectusplague in 29 counties, 134 occurrences ofMeriones unguiculatusplague in 23 counties, 104 occurrences ofRhombomys opimusplague in 16 counties, 109 occurrences ofMarmota baibacina-Spermophilus undulatusplague in 12 counties, 30 occurrences ofSpermophilus dauricusplague in 12 counties, 20 occurrences ofApodemus chevrieri-Eothenomys milrtusplague in 6 counties, 14 occurrences ofMicrotus brandtiplague in 4 counties, 15 occurrences ofMarmota sibiricaplague in 3 counties, 7 occurrences ofMarmota caudataplague in 3 counties, 3 occurrences ofSpermophilus alaschanicusplague in 2 counties, and 20 occurrences ofMicrotus fuscusin 1 county.
There were 244 occurrences in 49 counties of Xizang (Tibet) Autonomous Region; 234 occurrences in 35 counties of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region; 177 occurrences in 34 counties of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region; 59 occurrences in 26 counties of Yunnan Province; 80 occurrences in 19 counties of Qinghai Province; 56 occurrences in 10 counties of Sichuan Province; 88 occurrences in 6 counties of Gansu Province; 10 occurrences in 6 counties of Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region; 8 occurrences in 3 counties of Zhejiang Province; 4 occurrences in 2 counties of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous; 5 occurrences in 1 county of Hebei Province; 4 occurrences in 1 county of Guizhou Province; 1 occurrence in 1 county of Shaanxi Province; and 1 occurrence in 1 county each in Jilin, Liaoning, and Hunan provinces.
In terms of frequency of plague epizootics, 5 counties (2 in Gansu, 2 in Xinjiang, and 1 in Sichuan) experienced plague epizootics every year, 23 counties [7 in Xinjiang, 6 in Xizang (Tibet), 5 in Inner Mongolia, 3 in Gansu, and 2 in Qinghai] experienced plague epizootics between 10 and 19 times during the past 20 years; 55 counties [18 in Xizang (Tibet); 13 in Inner Mongolia; 11 in Xinjiang; 4 in each of Sichuan, Yunnan, and Qinghai; and 1 in Hebei] experienced plague epizootics between 5 and 9 times during the past 20 years; 113 counties experienced plague epizootics in fewer than 5 times during the past 20 years.
Based on the occurrence of human plague and plague epizootics in recent years and a comprehensive analysis of plague foci, etiology, transmission characteristics and other factors, the possibility of human plague in 2022 cannot be ruled out. The high-risk months for 2022 will be July to October, the medium-risk months are May, June and November, and other months are low-risk months.
The relative weights of significant risk factors of plague outbreaks (e.g. frequency, quiescent years of plague epizootics) were scored in consultation with experts (4). Risk probability ranking and risk impact ranking of 196 counties that had plague foci in the past 20 years were calculated and their Borda points were tallied [Borda=(196−Risk probability ranking)+(196−risk impact ranking)]. Overall, 30 county-level divisions with the highest risk were identified according to Borda point tallies and in consultation with experts (Table 1).
PLADs County Epidemic
frequencyNumber of
quiescent yearsRisk
probabilityRisk
impactBorda
pointsRank Inner Mongolia Siziwang 15 20 8 8 348 1 Inner Mongolia Erlianho 16 20 10 36 346 2 Inner Mongolia Huade 12 20 13 36 343 3 Inner Mongolia OtogBanner 10 20 15 36 341 4 Yunnan Menghai 5 19 54 1 337 5 Gansu Subei 20 20 1 59 332 6 Inner Mongolia Otog Front Banner 9 20 24 36 332 6 Gansu Aksay 20 20 2 59 331 8 Gansu Yumen 19 20 5 59 328 9 Yunnan Yulong 9 17 35 30 327 10 Gansu Sunan 18 20 7 59 326 11 Xizang (Tibet) Linzhou 17 20 9 59 324 12 Qinghai Wulan 18 19 12 59 321 13 Xizang (Tibet) Dangxiong 15 20 15 59 318 14 Xizang (Tibet) Gar 14 19 17 59 316 15 Yunnan Gucheng 5 19 48 30 314 16 Inner Mongolia Wuchuan 3 20 43 36 313 17 Xizang (Tibet) Jiangzi 8 20 22 59 311 18 Sichuan Batang 9 19 25 59 308 19 Sichuan Yajiang 5 20 33 59 300 20 Qinghai Tianjun 6 19 35 59 298 21 Sichuan Litang 6 19 35 59 298 21 Hebei Kangbao 5 17 69 36 287 23 Qinghai Dulan 2 20 61 59 272 24 Qinghai Qilian 5 16 61 59 272 24 Xizang (Tibet) Yadong 1 20 61 59 272 24 Yunnan Jianchuan 1 16 96 30 266 27 Xinjiang Midong 12 20 14 156 222 28 Xinjiang Wusu 20 20 3 177 212 29 Xinjiang Jinghe 20 20 5 177 210 30 Abbreviations: PLADs=provincial-level administrative divisions. Table 1.High-risk counties of human plague in China, 2022.
-
An occurrence of human plague has significant negative impact on an affected population and causes serious damage to normal life in the area (5). Strong emergency control measures requiring large amounts of resources are then needed to mitigate negative impact and damage.
Human plague risk assessment is based on several factors, such as plague epizootics characteristics, ground time of host animals, contact between host animals and human beings, and the virulence ofYersinia pestis. Risk assessments are sensitive to several related factors. For example, environmental factors of precipitation, temperature, vegetation, and land use indirectly affect the occurrence of human plague by influencing the survival and reproduction of animals and insects (6). Social factors, including healthcare and sanitary conditions, living standards, educational level, and religious beliefs and customs contribute to the occurrence and spread of human plague by increasing exposure to infected animals. When there is an outbreak of human plague abroad, the risk in China increases. Illegal hunting of infected animals in plague foci and long-distance transportation of prey increases the risk of human plague in other areas. Patients seeking medical treatment in other cities increases the risk of bringing plague into large and medium-sized cities. There is a risk of transmission from secondary hosts, that is, infection transmitted by contact with an infected host animal during its hibernation period in a plague foci. Natural disasters and large-scale engineering projects can lead to abnormal gathering of host animals, thus increasing the risk of human infection (7).
We identified 30 county-level divisions at high risk of human plague. However, unlisted divisions in our analyses are not risk-free but rather have a relatively lower risk. PLADs should take plague prevention and control measures in high-risk counties, cities, districts, and adjacent areas to prevent the spread of plague from animals to humans (8). At the beginning of each year, or during plague-prone seasons, PLADs should routinely conduct plague risk assessments and take timely and effective interventions in the plague foci areas based on risk assessment results.
-
All participants in this evaluation.
HTML
| Citation: |
|